California recently passed a landmark bill requiring a phased increase in the minimum wage for certain healthcare workers to $25 per hour. While this promises a significant pay raise for hundreds of thousands of workers, the impact on healthcare systems across the industry is a hot debate. Let’s delve into the nuances of this law and explore its potential benefits and consequences.
Statewide healthcare worker minimum wage is now a law in California
In October 2023, California Governor Gavin Newsom signed Senate Bill 525 into law, establishing a new minimum wage standard for healthcare workers at covered facilities. Despite some delays and setbacks, including an anticipated July 1, 2024, start date, the aptly named Healthcare Minimum Wage Law will now go into effect no later than January 1, 2025.
The law is intended to raise the pay floor for thousands of workers who are essential to both routine medical care and emergency response efforts, and yet are among the lowest-paid healthcare professionals. A wide range of workers are expected to benefit from this raise, including nurses, medical assistants, billing personnel, janitors, food service workers, front office staff, and more.
Of course, the wage increase won’t happen overnight. While some hospitals and integrated delivery networks (IDNs)have already notified their employees of the upcoming raise, or have already started to increase pay, most workers will see their pay gradually increase yearly until they reach the $25 per hour threshold.
How does the Healthcare Minimum Wage Law work?
The Healthcare Minimum Wage Law organizes California health facilities into four groups, each with a timeline to bring workers up to $25 per hour.
Under the new law, healthcare workers are categorized into four groups, determining what workers within each group can expect to make when the law takes effect. The table below outlines this in greater detail.
| Group # | Provider type | $18/hr | $21/hr | $23/hr |
| 1 | Health systems >10,000+ full-time employees | X | ||
| 1 | Dialysis clinics | X | ||
| 2 | Health systems <10,000 full-time employees | X | ||
| 3 | Hospitals with a high share of Medicare and Medi-Cal patients | X | ||
| 3 | Rural independent hospitals | X | ||
| 4 | Community clinics & primary care clinics | X | ||
| 4 | Behavioral health centers | X |
Each group also has its own timeline for when healthcare worker wage rates will increase. For example, the hourly minimum wage of healthcare professionals in Group 4, which includes those who work in various clinics, will increase to $21 by January 2025. It will increase again to $22 per hour by July 2026, and finally to $25 per hour by July 2027.
Regardless of group, all eligible healthcare workers can expect to reach $25 in the next few years. Once they’ve reached the threshold, the minimum wage will be annually adjusted for inflation or by 3.5%, whichever is lower.
Who benefits from the Healthcare Minimum Wage law?
The most immediate benefit obviously goes to the workers themselves. A $25 minimum wage translates to a much-needed financial boost for many people. According to the UC Berkeley Labor Center, the law will predominantly benefit workers of color and women who are currently struggling to make ends meet.
A pay increase can also help address other problems across the healthcare landscape, such as:
- Reducing stress and burnout: More pay can alleviate financial stress and improve the standard of living. This can lead to better job satisfaction, reduced burnout, higher morale, and possibly a more focused workforce committed to patient care.
- Combatting staffing shortages: Higher wages are an important means of attracting and retaining healthcare workers. A stable workforce also helps health systems perform more effectively and respond faster during emergencies.
- Staying competitive with other industries: Employers across multiple industries outside of healthcare are also raising the minimum wages of their workers. By offering higher pay, the California healthcare industry can remain competitive.
How will this impact the broader healthcare ecosystem?
The lingering questions lurking behind the new legislation are deeply complex. How will the rise in healthcare worker minimum wage impact health system finances moving forward? Will this set a precedent for other states?
The long-term implications of the Healthcare Minimum Wage law may be unclear for now, but we can make some assumptions. Increased labor costs could force hospitals and health systems to find ways to balance the budget. Our data shows that hospital salary expenses have been gradually increasing yearly, so the added cost of a higher minimum wage could apply greater financial pressure on some facilities.
To manage these expenses, facilities might reduce services or programs deemed less essential, raise the prices for certain procedures, or even resort to layoffs or staffing reductions. Any of these outcomes could be detrimental and limit patient access to certain types of care.
Rural hospitals may be particularly vulnerable. As these facilities often operate on tighter budgets and face greater staffing challenges compared to their urban counterparts, they could have a harder time absorbing the increased labor costs. This could potentially lead to facility closures or service reductions in these critically underserved areas.
Healthcare quality should be carefully monitored moving forward
California’s $25 minimum wage for healthcare workers is a bold step towards improving the lives of its healthcare workforce. Given the potential negative consequences, however, it’s crucial to monitor the law’s impact on healthcare systems and patient access to care moving forward. Striking a balance between a well-compensated workforce and a sustainable healthcare system will be key.
The Healthcare Minimum Wage law is complex and affects different healthcare providers at different times. Some types of providers might be entirely exempt. We encourage you to read the bill and its amendments, and the Department of Health Care Access and Information fact sheet to determine whether you are an eligible provider and how the law applies to you.
For more on the latest trends and events shaping the healthcare landscape, and the healthcare commercial intelligence you need to grow and compete, start a free trial today with Definitive Healthcare.
